Daniel Day-Lewis and Throwing Stones at Israeli Apartheid

Navigating Syrian activist Razan Ghazzawi’s blog last night, I came across the most interesting excerpt on her sidebar. It read:

[Israel] is a state of apartheid. It’s taken me less than a week to lose impartiality. In doing so, I may as well be throwing stones at tanks.

What caught my attention was that the quote was attributed to one of the most honey-01-650x830masterful actors of our time: Daniel Day-Lewis. At first, I wondered if this was another one of those popular misattributions to famous folks from overly zealous activists. It was, much to my surprise, not. The piece, written on March 20th 2005, is no longer available on the Times’ website. Despite this, I think Day-Lewis’ writing, observations, work and thoughts are profound and deserve to be read. I do not know, at this moment and time, if he still believes what he has written here — I find it hard to fathom that he does not. Regardless, do take a moment to read this piece which explores the psychological effects of occupation and violence.

Inside scarred minds

On his first visit to the Gaza Strip, Daniel Day-Lewis meets the Palestinian families living in the heart of the danger zone and the psychologists who are counselling them.

Mossa’ab, the interpreter, leads the way, carrying a white Medecins Sans Frontieres (MSF) flag. Its psychology team, myself and the photographer Tom Craig are in full view of an Israeli command post occupying the top floors of a large mill. It is draped in camouflage netting, as is the house close by. It is to this house that we are heading, across 200 yards of no man’s land; the last house left standing in an area once teeming with life.

Civilians have been the main victims of the violence inflicted by both sides in the Middle East conflict. In the Gaza Strip the Israeli army reacts to stone-throwing with bullets. It responds to the suicide bombs and attacks of Palestinian militants by bulldozing houses and olive groves in the search for the perpetrators, to punish their families, and to set up buffer zones to protect Israeli settlements. It bars access to villages, and multiplies checkpoints, cutting Gaza’s population off from the outside world. MSF’s psychologists are trying to help Palestinian families cope with the stress of living within these confines; visiting them, treating severe trauma and listening to their stories. Their visits are the only sign sometimes that they have not been abandoned.

Israel’s tanks and armour-plated bulldozers can come with no warning, often at night. The noise alone, to a people who have been forced to suffer these violations year after year, is enough to freeze the soul. Israeli snipers position themselves on rooftops. Householders are ordered to leave; they haven’t even the time to collect pots and pans, papers and clothes before the bulldozers crush the unprotected buildings like dinosaurs trampling on eggs ” sometimes first mashing one into another, then covering the remains with a scoop of earth. Those caught in the incursion zone will be fired on. Even those cowering inside their houses may be shot at or shelled through walls, windows and roofs. The white flag carried by humanitarian workers gives little protection; we’ll have warning shots fired at us twice before the week is out.

Sometimes a family will not leave an area that is being cleared, believing if they do leave they will lose everything. It is a huge risk to remain. Sometimes a house is left standing, singled out for occupation by Israeli troops. The family is forced to remain as protection for the soldiers. Last year an average of 120 houses were demolished each month, leaving 1,207 homeless every month. In the past four years 28,483 Gazans have been forcibly evicted; over half of Gaza’s usable land, mainly comprising citrus-fruit orchards, olive groves and strawberry beds, has been destroyed. Last year, 658 Palestinians were killed in the violence in Gaza, and dozens of Israelis. This ploughing under, house by house, orchard by orchard, reduces community to wasteland, strewn and embedded with a stunted crop of broken glass and nails, books, abandoned possessions. As we weave our way towards the home of Abu Saguer and his family ” one of several families we will visit today ” we are treading on shattered histories and aspirations.

Abu Saguer’s own house is still standing, but its top floor and roof are occupied by Israeli soldiers. His granddaughter Mervat is with us, a sweet, shy seven-year-old with red metal-rimmed glasses, her hair in two neat braids held by flowery bands. She wears bright-red trousers and a denim jacket. Last April her mother heard an Israeli Jeep pull up briefly at the military-access road in front of their house. Some projectile was fired and when Mervat reappeared ” she had been playing outside ” she was crying and her face was covered in blood. They washed her. Her right eye was crushed. A month later in Gaza an artificial eye was fitted. It was very uncomfortable, so a special recommendation was needed from the Palestinian Ministry of Health to finance a trip to Egypt for one that fitted properly. Mervat needs this eye changed every six months, so the ministry must negotiate with Israel each time for permission to cross the border. Fifty cars are permitted to cross each day; each must carry seven people.

Abu Saguer has five sons and four daughters  “You’ll go broke with more than that,” he says. He lives near the big checkpoint of Abu Houli in southern Gaza. He wants the photographer, Tom Craig, to take his picture and put it on every wall in England, Germany and Russia. He is 59. At 12 he went out to work, and at 16 he began to build the house he had dreamt of, “slowly, slowly” as a home and as a gathering place for his extended family. He had grown up in a house made of mud in Khan Yunis, which let the water in whenever it rained, and all his pride, hope and generosity of spirit had invested itself in this ambition. He had worked in Israel, like so many here, before the borders were closed to all men aged between 16 and 35.

For over 20 years, Abu Saguer had his own business, selling and transporting bamboo furniture. During the second Gulf war all his merchandise was stolen. After that he relied on his truck for income. He had cultivated 300 square metres of olive trees, pomegranates, palms, guavas and lemons in the fields around his home. After the start of the second intifada (Palestinian uprising) his crops were destroyed by the Israeli army ” for “security”. A road that services the Israeli settlements of Gush Katif had been built, and during our visit the traffic passes freely backwards and forwards, along the edge of the barren land where his orchards once flourished.
Scroll below share buttons to read on.

15 thoughts on “Daniel Day-Lewis and Throwing Stones at Israeli Apartheid

  1. As Jew I am not allowed to live in PA, Saoedie Arab, and a lot of more country’s.
    In Israel there are judges, doctors, ingenieurs part of the Israelian society.
    An Israely arab has all the same right as Israelian Jews.
    The only difference is that they do not have to go to the army, but the are allowed.
    And some of them do go.

  2. You are not allowed to live in Saudi Arabia, which is one of the worst countries in the world, so that’s a good comparison: Even the horrible Saudis don’t discriminate against people who they have occupied an made to suffer horrors for decades.

    Also, the article is talking about occupied Palestinians, not the Israeli citizens. To Israeli, they’re all in Israel. So basically you kick someone in the face, then complain about their face hitting your foot, then bomb them to pieces.

  3. apartheids staat ahould mean that residents are discriminated on ground of race, religion etc.
    In Israel this is not done.
    The from Jordan freed territories are not part of Israel.
    The laws followed there are the Jordan laws.

    Jews used to live in this territories before Jordan occupied it, in te cencus from 1845 and 1900 the bigges group in Jeruzalem where the Jews.
    So why should they not anymore have the right to live there just because Jordan expelled and killed them for 19 years (1948 – 1967).

  4. Even non citizen Arabs living in “Occupied Territories” are allowed to enter to Israel. Until second Intifada there were no checkpoints and the Arabs enter Israeli freely with vehicles the same way Belgians enter France. The need to stop that arrangement and to put fence and gates is due to only high aggression of Islamic terror of second intifada. Now more than 150,000 PA Arabs coming to work each day inside Israel.

    Saying that Israel is a State of Apartheid is extreme idiocy. That means that Jews haven’t right to defend themselves from ongoing Islamic daily terror. Muslim extremists used to launch daily rockets deliberately targeted at Israel civilians, and people had died. If Mexico to launch even one rocket at Texas I’m sure that US army wouldn’t leave stone un-touched in the area from where the rocket was launched, not matter the near-by civilians. Israel stopped, not once, aerial attacks that found to host civilians inside or near-by at the midst of the attack/ No other army does it.

    Hamas use civilians, mainly kids, as human shield for their terror attackers, knowing well that if Israel will detect it on time they will hold the attack, but if the Israel didn’t see it by their intelligence, than it will cost the dead of the kids, which will enable Hamas to blame Israel as “children murderer”. But the real murderers are Hamas itself.

    Listen to what one of the high ranking Hamas leader has to say on the matter: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RTu-AUE9ycs


  6. Pingback: Are Israeli Jews the most racist people on Earth? - Page 461

  7. IsraeWorst, how dare you blame the Palestinians for rising up against the humiliation of the occupation.. If Palestinians were living in peace and dignity then there would not be a first, a second, and now a third Intifada. The fact is that anyone with a shred of human decency will stand with the Palestinian cause when they learn about what’s really happening on the ground. Which is what is happening with people when visiting “the stolen land of Israel”, and Israelis hate it when these things come out because it defies the system they have put together to prevent the truth from coming out, controlling the media and Hollywood, so even if Daniel Day Lewis dares to ask for an interview with CNN or NBC to share his findings, the Oscar award winner will never get a chance or will get a brief moment then be called and anti-Semite and be damned for life just like what happened to Helen Thomas and others in the past.

    Saying that Hamas is using the Palestinian civilians as human shields was the number 1 excuse by all Israeli officials during the last massacre in Gaza for killing 100’s of children and women, which was denied by the UN analysis. There are still efforts to try to take the Israel PM to criminal court for this.

    No one buys your Zionist propaganda bs anymore..

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s